Religious Accommodations in the Workplace: Evolving Standards & Consistent Applications
Accommodation for employees with disabilities is often top of mind for employers. However, requests for religious accommodation require the same level of attention, preparation, and consideration. Employers must understand their legal obligations and establish processes that ensure religious accommodation requests are handled consistently, fairly, and respectfully.
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires employers to provide reasonable accommodations for an applicant or employee whose sincerely held religious beliefs, practices, or observances conflict with a work requirement, unless doing so would impose an undue hardship on the employer. Although this fundamental requirement has remained consistent, the legal standard for determining what constitutes an “undue hardship” has evolved. In addition, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) has stepped up enforcement in this area, making now a good time for employers to reevaluate their compliance efforts.
The Past and Present of the “Undue Hardship Standard”
In Trans World Airlines, Inc. v. Hardison (1977), an employee joined a religious organization that observed the Sabbath from sunset Friday to sunset Saturday informed his employer that he could no longer work on Saturdays. The Supreme Court held that Title VII did not require the employer to bear more than a de minimis (minimal) cost to accommodate the employee's religious practices. This interpretation established a relatively low threshold for employers to demonstrate undue hardship.
However, the standard was elevated in Groff v. DeJoy (2023). In this case, Groff, a postal employee, requested an exemption from Sunday work due to his religious observances. The Supreme Court’s decision updated the threshold of undue hardship, requiring that employers show an accommodation would result in “substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of its particular business,” which is more akin to the standard for accommodations for those with a disability.
Because determining whether a cost is "substantial" requires a highly fact-intensive inquiry tailored to a business's specific size, operating costs, and revenue, courts are increasingly denying early dismissals of these cases. In addition, the Supreme Court also clarified that impacts on coworkers matter only if they directly spill over to affect the conduct of the business itself. Since DeJoy, courts have routinely found that co-worker animosity towards a particular religious belief, or a general hostility toward religious accommodations cannot be used to claim undue hardship.
The EEOC is Active
The EEOC's National Enforcement Plan for 2025-2029 specifically highlights religious discrimination as an enforcement priority. The plan noted plans to prioritize claims against employers who tolerate religion-based harassment or deny reasonable accommodation based on a sincerely-held religious belief.
True to its word, the EEOC has unleashed a wave of high-profile enforcement actions related to religious discrimination in the workplace. For example, in late October, 2026, a charge against a Reno-based logistics company resulted in a settlement of $360,000 after an employee allegedly faced offensive comments regarding their Jewish faith from both co-workers and management.
The agency has also pursued smaller matters, demonstrating that no employer is immune from an EEOC inquiry in this area. In September 2026, for example, the EEOC filed a lawsuit against a New York City coffee shop alleging that a manager denied the request of a short-term shift modification to accommodate a Muslim employee during the Islamic holy month of Ramadan. Following the denial, the employee was terminated. The lawsuit concluded with the coffee shop paying $22,500 as well as additional relief to the terminated employee.
One area where the EEOC has been particularly active is examining how employers handle requests for religious accommodations to vaccine policies. At the end of September 2026, the EEOC reached a $2.8 million dollar settlement with a New Mexico-based laboratory management company. In this case, as well as several other recent cases, the EEOC claimed the employer refused to provide religious or disability-related accommodations to its COVID-19 vaccine mandate and testing policy.
Setting Up for Success
Employers should establish a consistent process for handling a religious accommodation request that is within easy reach of all employees. Policies should apply fairly to all employees, regardless of position, tenure, or department.
Effective policies and procedures should:
-
Provide guidance at onset of employment. Make the accommodation policy and instructions for submitting requests known during onboarding stage and ensure it is accessible throughout employment.
-
Clearly communicate employee rights. Employees should understand that requesting religious accommodation is within their legal rights. Employees should feel confident that no form of retaliation will be made against them during the accommodation review process and/or after a decision is made, regardless of the outcome.
-
Explain the request process. Clearly outline the steps employees should follow such as advance notice expectations, the point of contact, and any information that will assist in a timely review. Explain that while requests are being reviewed, additional questions may be asked to determine the ideal solution for all parties.
-
Establish a welcoming workplace. Employees should feel comfortable seeking accommodation and that their requests will be considered without bias. Employers may work to identify no cost ways of acknowledging various cultures, religions and practices. A small act such as noting religious or culture events to the company calendar may foster a welcoming culture.
-
Develop a centralized recordkeeping process. Employers will also want to consider developing a centralized recordkeeping process that demonstrates consistency and good faith in handling accommodation requests. Centralizing recordkeeping also ensures the company applies identical standards across all departments and that records regarding the interactive process are easily retrievable should a charge of discrimination or lawsuit be filed.
-
Train managers. Teach managers about the company’s obligation to provide reasonable accommodations for sincerely-held religious beliefs and make sure they understand that they should not deny a request without talking to HR. Make sure managers can recognize an accommodation request even if the employee doesn't use formal legal terms like "Title VII," or "reasonable accommodation."
When all parties are aware of their role in the accommodation review process, it helps produce a partnership and allows employees to feel heard, valued and respected, while also ensuring accommodation requests are managed appropriately from a legal risk perspective.
Keep an Open Mind
Religious accommodation requests should be approached with an open mind and a willingness to understand the employee's circumstances. Under Title VII, religious beliefs and practices are not confined to traditional, organized religions, and a practice does not need to be formally required by a religious organization to qualify.
Employers generally should not require employees to provide proof of their religious affiliation or obtain documentation from a religious leader as a component of the evaluation process. However, employers may ask reasonable follow-up questions when clarification is needed to understand the request or determine a suitable accommodation.
The objective is to have a constructive dialogue between employer and employee to understand the religious needs while at the same time keeping the employer's business needs in mind as well as the rest of the employee population. An employer does not have to grant the employee's preferred accommodation, and alternatives that reasonably accommodate the employee's religious practice without imposing an undue hardship on the company can be considered.
-1.png)
.png?width=593&name=MicrosoftTeams-image%20(4).png)